Back to Gibson Home Everyday Essential Cobalt Dinnerware Set, 12-Piece Set

Customer reviews

4 out of 5stars
(18 reviews)

Most helpful positive review

5.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
09/11/2020
Amazing quality dinnerware!
These are some substantial dishes! I am very impressed with the overall quality of them. They are heavy and sturdy. They have a very modern look the them, with a very flat bottom and a slightly rounded edge. The set looks so nice and I'm going to display them on my open shelves. The only downfall is that when stacked they do get really high. But they don't act like they would topple over so it might be ok! I highly recommend these if you're looking for new quality dishes. They did not disappoint!
Brittany

Most helpful negative review

2.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
12/02/2021
DISAPPOINTED
The dish sets (bought 2) are very heavy and not what I had hoped they would be like. Very disappointed that I now have to lug to store to return them. Descriptions of items online should be more detailed about specifics instead of being written as a tribute to each item. Unfortunately, stores do not carry enough variety and stock to be able to be selective but instead shoppers have to accept what they have or purchase online and still not get what they want.
Debbie
14 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    08/11/2023
    Pottery Barn dupe
    These are awesome!!! I got them for my college student and i am seriously thinking about replacing my entire pottery barn set with these! They are that cute!!
    Alison
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    08/04/2023
    don't wait...buy them!!
    I love these plates!!!! I saw similar style on Amazon for $400. I wasn't about to spend that and came across these. They are high quality, modern but also rustic. Absolutely recommend!!
    Rebecca
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    06/26/2023
    Great Farmhouse Style Stoneware
    This set is exactly what I was looking for and arrived on time despite coming all the way from California. I was a little concerned when the FedEx driver dropped them on my concrete porch but they are packaged with great care and attention paid to protect each item. My only disappointment is that some of the plates have paint drips on them and they look kinda odd with that on them but I still like the design and the farmhouse style and I figure once they have food on them it won't be as noticeable. I haven't gotten to use them yet but I'm hoping I'm going to get to move back to my hometown soon and I am set for a fresh everything. Out with the old and on to my new cookware and dinnerware etc. I hope they will last for years to come. Definitely don't want to drop these as they are stoneware. I'd have rated 5 stars if they didn't have the cosmetic defects but I would most definitely recommend them!!
    MichelleB
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    10/09/2022
    Pretty color, too heavy.
    These plates are quite heavy and the edges are unglazed. That seems to be part of the look, but touching those edges for me is like fingernails on a chalkboard. Pretty color, though.
    Neely
  • 3.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/19/2022
    Just want a complete set
    One of my bowls was broken. Hoping it will get replaced.
    Kimberly
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/27/2021
    Nice but one salad plate chipped
    Really liked the dishes, quality seemed nice. My only complaint is one of the salad dishes was chipped and I am having trouble figuring out how to contact for a replacement without returning all of the dishes. Hoping there will be a reply to this review. Thank you
    April
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/10/2021
    Beautiful Dishes
    Ordered a set of black and a set of blue with the intention of choosing between one of the colors but I don't think I can. The dishes are just like the picture. Very elegant, bowls are large enough to hold an adult portion of soup. Dishes are weighted but not heavy. I only worry that my utensils will scratch them up or how they will do in the dishwasher but for now so pretty couldn't have asked for better. Everything came fast and in tact with very nice packing to ensure nothing broke during transit.
    Jailyn
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    12/02/2021
    DISAPPOINTED
    The dish sets (bought 2) are very heavy and not what I had hoped they would be like. Very disappointed that I now have to lug to store to return them. Descriptions of items online should be more detailed about specifics instead of being written as a tribute to each item. Unfortunately, stores do not carry enough variety and stock to be able to be selective but instead shoppers have to accept what they have or purchase online and still not get what they want.
    Debbie
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    07/03/2021
    Not for me.
    These could have been awesome. They show scratches even though the color is dark. They also have an abrasive unfinished edge on top and bottom that will scratch your kitchen and dining surfaces depending on the materials. Not for me. Going back.
    bobbi
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/10/2021
    Great purchase!
    Super nice!, they are heavy and nice sized. The bowls are amazing, the plate makes anything you serve on it look great! Only downfall was that 2 plates were broken but I still opted not to ship them back because there were no more sets available on line. Since I've purchased them I use them daily and are dishwasher safe, no problems, no scratches.
    Isela
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/22/2020
    Amazing dishes but...
    I am obsessed with these dishes. I love how there is no nonsense with the plates and the bowls. The plates go all the way to the rim and the tiny lip prevents any type of spillage. The bowls are deep enough to where when I walk with soup or cereal I don't feel like anything is going to spill out. They are super sturdy and with 3 kids 7 and under, I need that. The color is perfect because it goes with everything. The only thing that I don't enjoy is the rim is I guess what you would call an unfinished porcelain or ceramic, I'm not sure the exact material. It's a texture thing for me bc it feels like gritty sandpaper or something. But that could be overlooked for most I'm sure.
    Cole
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/17/2020
    Love the Bowl Size!
    I really like this set of plates – especially the bowls. During the whole pandemic thing, I've been eating more at home. When I'm feeling particularly lazy, I've been making packaged ramen at home. I add a bunch of vegetables and an egg, which makes for a sizable serving that doesn't fit in some of my bowls. However, my ramen meal fits easily in these large bowls! For once, I don't have to worry about accidentally spilling broth over the sides as I carry the bowl to the table. The wide base of the bowl gives it lots of stability too. So happy! I like the design of this set, including the slightly rustic edge. The dishes look casual and warm, in my opinion. I also enjoy the look of the distinctly raised lip on the edges of the plates – which serves the useful purpose of making sure no salad dressings or sauces slide off the edge of the plate. Regarding durability: just today, my husband lifted one of the bowls to put it in the microwave. As he lifted the bowl, he fumbled and knocked it around a bit on our granite countertop. The bowl survived this slight mishap, so I have high hopes for the durability of this dish set. I received the white set free has a spark reviewer, but I may go back and purchase the yellow set. That says something, doesn't it?
    DesertRat
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/17/2020
    Love the Bowl Size!
    I really like this set of plates – especially the bowls. During the whole pandemic thing, I’ve been eating more at home. When I’m feeling particularly lazy, I’ve been making packaged ramen at home. I add a bunch of vegetables and an egg, which makes for a sizable serving that doesn’t fit in some of my bowls. However, my ramen meal fits easily in these large bowls! For once, I don’t have to worry about accidentally spilling broth over the sides as I carry the bowl to the table. The wide base of the bowl gives it lots of stability too. So happy! I like the design of this set, including the slightly rustic edge. The dishes look casual and warm, in my opinion. I also enjoy the look of the distinctly raised lip on the edges of the plates – which serves the useful purpose of making sure no salad dressings or sauces slide off the edge of the plate. Regarding durability: just today, my husband lifted one of the bowls to put it in the microwave. As he lifted the bowl, he fumbled and knocked it around a bit on our granite countertop. The bowl survived this slight mishap, so I have high hopes for the durability of this dish set. I received the white set free has a spark reviewer, but I may go back and purchase the yellow set. That says something, doesn’t it?
    DesertRat
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/11/2020
    Amazing quality dinnerware!
    These are some substantial dishes! I am very impressed with the overall quality of them. They are heavy and sturdy. They have a very modern look the them, with a very flat bottom and a slightly rounded edge. The set looks so nice and I’m going to display them on my open shelves. The only downfall is that when stacked they do get really high. But they don’t act like they would topple over so it might be ok! I highly recommend these if you’re looking for new quality dishes. They did not disappoint!
    Brittany
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/11/2020
    Amazing quality dinnerware!
    These are some substantial dishes! I am very impressed with the overall quality of them. They are heavy and sturdy. They have a very modern look the them, with a very flat bottom and a slightly rounded edge. The set looks so nice and I'm going to display them on my open shelves. The only downfall is that when stacked they do get really high. But they don't act like they would topple over so it might be ok! I highly recommend these if you're looking for new quality dishes. They did not disappoint!
    Brittany
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/09/2020
    So great for everyday use!
    Nice thick porcelain that I can trust my kids with! Easy care plates and bowls, wash easily in the dishwasher. The matte color of the porcelain looks chic and high end, like from a catalog store. I especially like the raw edge trim, which looks a bit primitive in its styling, which blends well in our “rustic” look kitchen. They shipped quickly, and arrived in pristine condition. Right out of the box they looked great next to our other designer tableware, that we save for special occasions. The bowls are petite, but a great size for snacks. I was able to use them in the microwave which was a deal-maker for me, as some more expensive plates we own, aren't allowed in there. I heated up some wheat cereal and they hold heat well, rather than getting scalding hot like melamine plates do. These were a win for my family, since they seem durable. The quality was great, I was shocked they were from a value brand.
    SoCalMeegal
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    09/09/2020
    So great for everyday use!
    Nice thick porcelain that I can trust my kids with! Easy care plates and bowls, wash easily in the dishwasher. The matte color of the porcelain looks chic and high end, like from a catalog store. I especially like the raw edge trim, which looks a bit primitive in its styling, which blends well in our “rustic” look kitchen. They shipped quickly, and arrived in pristine condition. Right out of the box they looked great next to our other designer tableware, that we save for special occasions. The bowls are petite, but a great size for snacks. I was able to use them in the microwave which was a deal-maker for me, as some more expensive plates we own, aren’t allowed in there. I heated up some wheat cereal and they hold heat well, rather than getting scalding hot like melamine plates do. These were a win for my family, since they seem durable. The quality was great, I was shocked they were from a value brand.
    SoCalMeegal
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    08/17/2020
    Nice plates- not nice shipping
    Love the way these look and feel, however, mine arrived broken and I have not been given an option for replacement!
    KLG2008